Beyond Compliance: The Shift from Obedience to Discipline in Leadership and Life

As a young officer in the Ranger Regiment, I adhered strictly to the Ranger Standards. Those standards are what made us who we were – and so my thinking went. Rangers were the most disciplined warriors because we adhered to our standards – always, all the time. However, my experiences, especially through combat tours and following innovative Ranger leaders, radically reshaped my understanding of discipline. It dawned on me that the spit-shined boots and starched fatigues of the 1990s, while emblematic of military obedience, didn’t fully encapsulate the essence of true discipline. This revelation became increasingly clear as I observed the actions of Rangers in the crucible of combat post-9/11, where the line between discipline and obedience distorted and then redefined itself in the most profound ways.

In the 1990s, the Ranger Regiment was emblematic of military standards with spit-shined boots, starched fatigues, and weekly haircuts. If you want to know what the best warrior in the military should look like, look no further than the Ranger Regiment. But was this a true display of discipline, or was it obedience? Often, we blur the lines between the two, yet they are fundamentally distinct.

In the post-2001 era, my understanding of discipline versus obedience evolved profoundly, particularly through combat experiences with the Regiment. The battlefield illuminated the essence of true discipline. I observed Rangers consistently doing the right thing, not out of fear of consequences, but because it was inherently the right action to take. Actions that might have been deemed “undisciplined” in the Regiment’s pre-war days were now essential for survival and success. Combat, in its unfiltered reality, distilled the important from the unimportant, revealing that true discipline is about making sound decisions under pressure, guided by internal principles rather than external enforcement.

The evolution from obedience to discipline is a critical transition, particularly in high-stakes environments like the military. Obedience, while important for structure and order, often operates under the premise of compliance without question. However, true discipline, especially in unpredictable and dynamic combat situations, requires more. It demands a deeper understanding, critical thinking, and a commitment to doing what is right, not just what is ordered. This shift is essential for effective decision-making under pressure, where adherence to principles and mission objectives becomes paramount. Embracing discipline over mere obedience cultivates leaders who are not only effective in following orders but also capable of making sound judgments in the absence of directives.

This vital distinction between discipline and obedience transcends the military and holds profound implications in the civilian world. In corporate environments, education, and daily life, understanding this difference equips individuals to act with integrity and initiative. Discipline in this broader context means making decisions aligned with core values and long-term goals, rather than merely following procedures or directives. It fosters innovative thinking, personal accountability, and ethical leadership. In a world that increasingly values autonomy and critical thinking, nurturing a culture of discipline over obedience is key to personal growth, effective leadership, and the creation of more dynamic, responsive, and responsible organizations and communities.

Discipline is about making the right choices for the right reasons, irrespective of potential consequences. It’s a trait that often operates in the face of fear, driven by courage rather than the avoidance of repercussions. Obedience, on the other hand, is compliance due to the fear of consequences. It’s about following orders, not necessarily internalizing the reasons behind them.

The word ‘discipline’ comes from the Latin disciplina, meaning to instruct or pass on knowledge. True discipline is about learning, growing, and internalizing values so deeply that they guide our actions, even when no one is watching. It’s about self-mastery, not external compliance.

Understanding the difference between discipline and obedience is crucial, not just on the battlefield but in life. Throughout our journey, there will be moments calling for both, but recognizing which one you’re practicing is crucial to our self-understanding and our development. Here are some thoughts to cultivate true discipline:

• Understand Your ‘Why’: Identify and internalize the reasons behind your actions. Discipline comes from a place of understanding and agreement with these reasons.

• Practice Self-Reflection: Regularly reflect on your actions. Are they driven by fear of consequences or by a commitment to doing the right thing?  Be honest with yourself.

• Build Courage: Cultivate the courage to make the right decisions, especially when they’re difficult or when they go against the grain.

• Foster Continuous Learning: Embrace learning as a lifelong process. Discipline is as much about acquiring knowledge as it is about applying it.

• Consistency in Action: Work towards being consistent in your actions, regardless of the presence of an external authority.

By embracing true discipline, we open ourselves to a journey of continuous learning and self-improvement. It’s a path that requires courage, understanding, and a commitment to personal growth. Let’s strive to be disciplined, not just obedient, in our pursuit of excellence.

*Note: this subject is discussed in greater depth in my book with Dr. Alice Atalanta – Meditations of an Army Ranger: A Warrior Philosophy for Everyone which can be purchased here: https://hatterasnav.us/prodromosbooks/

_____________________________

This first appeared in The Havok Journal on December 26, 2023.

J.C. served in the U.S. Army as an infantry officer for 20 years, primarily in special operations and special missions units with more than 11 combat tours. Since retiring from the military, JC has brought his innovative and unconventional thoughts on education, leadership and resiliency into the private sector, consulting with Fortune 500 companies, the NFL, NBA, NCAA and professional sports teams including the Denver Broncos, Carolina Panthers and the Charlotte Hornets.

He holds a Masters Degree from the Naval War College and was a Senior Fellow in the Service Chief’s Fellowship at the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA).

He has earned 3 Bronze Stars, 3 Meritorious Service Medals, a Joint Commendation Medal, and  the Order of Saint Maurice. He is a Liberty Fellow, a part of The Aspen Institute and the Aspen Global Leadership Network.

As the Voice of the Veteran Community, The Havok Journal seeks to publish a variety of perspectives on a number of sensitive subjects. Unless specifically noted otherwise, nothing we publish is an official point of view of The Havok Journal or any part of the U.S. government.