Edan Alexander, the Last US Hostage Held by Hamas, Is Now Free. It Only Took 580 Days.

Editor’s Note: the image used for this article is AI generated and intended to represent a generalized hostage release, not necessarily that of Edan Alexander.

---

Edan Alexander is finally home. After 580 days of captivity in Gaza, the last known American hostage held by Hamas has been released—bringing to a close a harrowing ordeal that began on October 7, 2023, when the terrorist group launched an unprecedented attack against Israel.

Born in Tel Aviv and raised in Tenafly, New Jersey, the 20-year-old U.S.-Israeli dual national was serving with the Israel Defense Forces’ Golani Brigade when he was abducted during the initial wave of Hamas’ invasion. Reports indicate he was taken near the Nahal Oz base, one of the first military targets to be overrun during the massacre that left over 1,200 Israelis and dozens of foreign nationals dead.

Since that moment, Alexander became a symbol of what it means to be forgotten in the fog of global politics.

---

A 580-Day Silence

For over a year and a half, his whereabouts were unknown. Hamas offered no proof of life. His name rarely made headlines. While other hostages were exchanged in earlier deals—many of them foreign nationals or women and children—Edan’s fate remained a question mark.

His family endured more than a year of anguish, lobbying tirelessly for action. For too long, they received little more than silence from the international community. In a world saturated with noise, Edan’s name was often a whisper.

That changed last week.

Thanks to Qatar and Egypt-brokered negotiations, Alexander was finally freed along with three other Israeli hostages. He was handed over near the Rafah crossing, checked by medics, and immediately flown to an Israeli military hospital for evaluation. The image of him, arms outstretched as he returned to Israeli soil, will join the long line of emotional homecomings etched in the memory of a nation under siege.

---

What Took So Long?

It’s a fair question—and one that deserves more than a diplomatic shrug.

Many have praised the released–as they should–with some calling it a “moment of profound relief.” But critics, including members of the veteran and national security communities, are asking: why 580 days? Why did it take so long to bring home a young man who fought against terrorism as part of an allied force?

The answer is part geopolitics, part inertia. Hostage diplomacy in the Middle East is a brutal chess game, and Americans held by groups like Hamas or Hezbollah often find hostages from countries who actually care about their people useful as bargaining chips in broader power plays involving Iran, Qatar, and other regional actors. U.S. leverage is inconsistent, and political will tends to surge only when media pressure reaches a boiling point.

Additionally, in Edan’s case, he was a soldier in the Israeli military and taken during a terrorist attack that Hamas considers part of an ongoing war. For Hamas, that made him both valuable—and, as far as Hamas was concerned, expendable, more like currency than a human being.

---

The Bigger Picture: Hostage as Strategy

Edan’s release is a victory, but it also shines a spotlight on a dark strategy: hostage-taking is back on the world stage as a viable, deliberate tactic. Indeed, it never really left. From Gaza to Ukraine to Iran, Americans and Westerners are being captured not for what they’ve done—but for what they can offer in political ransom.

And the response? Too often, it’s reactive rather than proactive.

What message does it send when a U.S. citizen has to wait nearly two years for freedom while his captors enjoy legitimacy at international negotiating tables? When terrorists dictate the timeline and terms of release, we have to ask: who really has the leverage?

In order to keep this kind of thing from happening in the future, potential hostage takers need to learn that they stand to lose far more by taking our people as hostages than they might gain by taking and holding them. America would do well to actively join in the effort to completely destroy Hamas as a functioning governmental organization and let it be known that any other similar organization who dares to violently seize and hold our citizens–especially when that organization is propped up by U.S. dollars—runs the risk of obliteration.

---

Welcome Home, Edan

Today is not about politics, though. It’s about a soldier who survived. It’s about resilience. It’s about a family who never gave up.

Edan Alexander is free.

But for the next American taken, for the next warfighter kidnapped behind enemy lines, the clock will start again.

How many days will it take next time?

---

Scott is a veteran of a half-dozen combat deployments and has served in several different Special Operations units over the course of his Army career. Scott’s writing focuses largely on veterans’ issues, but he is also a big proponent of Constitutional rights and has a deep interest in politics. He often allows other veterans who request anonymity to publish their work under his byline. Scott welcomes story ideas and feedback on his articles and can be reached at havokjournal@havokmedia.com. 

As the Voice of the Veteran Community, The Havok Journal seeks to publish a variety of perspectives on a number of sensitive subjects. Unless specifically noted otherwise, nothing we publish is an official point of view of The Havok Journal or any part of the U.S. government.